Recently a brand that has received a fair amount of backlash from the Youtube Beauty Community is “Too Faced”. They are well-known for their more expensive high and makeup and unique fruity collections that they have been pushing out in recent years. I personally selected them because I am a huge makeup enthusiast and I have a few of their holiday collection sets. However, just a few weeks back, many people in the community were shocked by one of Too Faced’s employe comment on a trans beauty guru’s coming out story. The comments were received as negative and reflected badly on the company.
Too Faced’s value proposition heavily relies on the quality of their makeup product. Their shadows are known to be pigmented and blendable. They also enjoy giving their products fruity and chocolaty scents and names, while at the same time heavily focusing on the packaging and presentation of the makeup products. This is how they primarily engage their customer base because customers see something that no other brands offer.
On the other hand talk about one of Too Faced’s employee’s comments has spurred outrage from the beauty community. As of now, multiple articles have been written denouncing the whole company as transphobic because of the comments. For instance, one article I found from Nylon.com was claiming that not only were the comments transphobic but that the “beauty community is vowing to boycott the brand for good”. On Instagram, various makeup enthusiasts were disgusted by the employee’s comments and were claiming that perhaps the bran’s name of “Too Faced” was fitting and well thought out because they were engaging in two-faced behavior. Lastly, I found a tweet of the YouTuber that was deeply hurt by the transphobic comments of Too Faced. In the tweet, she seemed to have expressed deep regret that she ever signed a contract with them and that she ever liked the brand, to begin with.
Too Faced is a makeup company they sell products ranging from palettes all the way to skincare and primers that enhance the effectiveness of their makeup. Being rejected and called out by the beauty community is extremely bad for them because that is where their customers come from.
Too Faced’s marketing heavily relies on its partnership with brands and Instagram/youtube influencers. For instance, Too Faced has a partnership with both Ulta Beauty and Sephora where they offer exclusive items that aren’t offered anywhere else. In regards to their partnerships with influencers, this is by far the most important part of their marketing strategy because they essentially have beauty influencers review their products on their channel which exposes their audience to the products and bring attention to the brand. Because this is Too Faced’s primary marketing strategy, the recent scandal with the trans YouTuber looks bad on them because all that past great work of influencer raving about the brand and quality is undone.
However, the company didn’t just let their good name go to waste, just after the scandal Too Faced quickly responded by letting go of the employee who had made those horrible comments to let their customers know that this wasn’t something they were supporting. I think this was a good decision on their part because the scandal was starting to ruin their image. You can’t always control what people within your company do and when someone does something wrong it is good to show their customers that that is not something they stand for or tolerate.
If I were a brand manager I would have done something similar. The first step was to definitely let go of the employee that made the comments. I would have taken it a step further by putting out a public apology regarding what was said. Aside from that, I would take steps to make the brand more inclusive and supportive of people that are part of the LGBTQ.
What I took away from this assignment is that it is important to listen to your customer base whenever they are saying something good or bad about your brand because scandals have the potential to completely shatter your brand’s image. It is also more than just listening but acting according to the criticisms you are receiving and making things right.